Hey America, Let’s Talk About What Divides Us

After the 2016 election, journalists Jeremy Hay and Eve Pearlman saw a need for better dialogue among ideological opponents. “Just the increase in discord, and real lack of civility and decline in trust in media,” Pearlman explains. “We started thinking, what could we do to do something different?”

Their answer is what they call ‘dialogue journalism.’ That is, “going to the heart of divides,” Pearlman says. “Bringing communities together in dialogue across difference, supporting those conversations with fact.” Their nonprofit Spaceship Media works with news organizations to facilitate discussions around the nation’s most divisive topics, like gun control, gentrification, and immigration. The conversations are constructed with the underlying belief that there is power when you provide a place where people can be curious.

In this podcast, we speak to two people who were selected to be part of a closed, moderated Facebook discussion on gun control, which Spaceship Media organized. Eric Truax introduced himself as an NRA member and Second Amendment supporter; Asheenia Johnson as an anti-violence activist. They both admit they held their own assumptions about those on the opposite side of the gun debate when they applied to take part in the spring. And, as you can hear, they both agree that they learned things about themselves, and about the other side, from the conversation.

“What I learned most from this group is that we’re not nearly as far apart from each other as I thought before. When we turn off the noise, it seems that we agree on most goals and vary on ways to fix it. That is very encouraging to me.” – Eric Truax

 

“I didn’t think that it was going to be that easy to talk to someone whose views I thought were much different than mine. But, as the conversation went on, I realized that if you’re not yelling at somebody, typing in all-caps and calling someone names, you really can have a meaningful conversation, and you may not agree, but at least at the end of the conversation, you understand.” – Asheenia Johnson

 

“We believe there’s profound value in a gun control advocate sharing real dialogue with a second amendment supporter. We don’t claim to have all the answers. We don’t claim to have solved it, but underpinning our work is: can we put community in the center of our work?” – Eve Pearlman

Additional Resources:

Spaceship Media projects

Nieman Lab: Can 5,000 strangers have a productive Facebook dialogue? Spaceship Media is about to try

Journalism.co.uk: Spaceship Media is using ‘dialogue journalism’ to enable productive conversations between communities at odds

Quartz: A Facebook experiment with California liberals and Alabama conservatives suggests belief, not facts, are what really divide us

Featured Image: People from around the nation took part in the ‘Guns: An American Conversation’ workshop in Washington, D.C. in March 2018. Credit: Seth Siditsky/Advance Local

 

1 Comment

  1. Mark Irons

    “# this is our lane”. Emergency doctors know what’s at stake. they have credibility. The NRA really stepped in it. It seems hash tag movements are the new tend for activism. Anything that works.

    It’s hard to believe how dangerous it is for a black person to hold a legal weapon even in an open carry state. RACISM and lack of police training.

    Everything these people are saying is true. That’s great but it doesn’t move the needle.

Leave a Comment